REFUSAL has been recommended by Monmouth Town Council with regards to the proposed flood defence system at Agincourt School.

The school, formerly Dixton Cottage, has applied for a four-and-a-half foot by six-and-a-half foot embankment to be built, protecting the building from flood waters from the river Wye.

However, councillors feel this may add to the problems by holding the water and directing it to the nearby church.

Councillor Tim Buckland expressed his concern as to the effectiveness of the scheme.

"I am doubtful as to the efficacy of this scheme," he said.

"The water comes from different directions, and we have received a letter of objection from the church."

His apprehension was echoed by local historian Keith Kissack, who used to live in the cottage.

His recollections of floodwater coming up from the Wye, the Monnow and even up through the floorboards was conveyed to the council through a letter.

He explained that the church, one of the oldest historical buildings in the area, would receive the brunt of the water, and Councillor Anthea Dewhurst voiced her concerns as to whether the church was actually consulted.

Summing up the matter, the town council decided a full investigation would need to be made into the effects of the embankment.

"It's a nonsense to enclose the area," said Councillor Dermot Downes.

"If they raise the banks, where would the soil go?"

"It will just serve to worsen the problems already there."

Kay Spencer, chair of the Haberdashers governors, said the school has sought advice from n independent consultant engineer specialising in flood defence, on how best to protect the school from flooding.

She explained the school's aim is to protect the listed building to ensure a high quality environment for its pupils and staff.

"The flood defences already in place include stumps and pumps - the pumps have helped to alleviate the problem of water seeping from underground," she said.

"However, they are keen to protect the building from rising river levels by constructing an earth bund in an arc around the school."

"The school has worked closely with the environment agency and was reassured that building the bind would not affect other properties in the area by raising water levels elsewhere."